The Show: A NY Post baseball podcast with Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman

148
Baseball #79

On the New York Post's baseball podcast "The Show with Joel Sherman and Jon Heyman," the veteran MLB insiders and longtime friends and combatants go toe-to-toe on the latest MLB news and issues of the week.The Post columnists have been arguing about baseball since competing as New York Yankees beat writers in their 20s (Yes, a while ago!). Now, finally on the same team, they get to take their three decades of baseball debates public, showing off their knowledge and revealing rumors and inside info from around Major League Baseball. "The Show", the best baseball podcast around, is released every Tuesday.

Recent Episodes
  • Yankees May Need to Consider Trading Devin Williams + Orioles GM Mike Elias Addresses Rough Start to Season
    May 7, 2025 – 50:14
  • Steve Cohen Isn't Worried About Juan Soto's Slow Start + Yankees remove Devin Williams From Closer Role
    Apr 28, 2025 – 47:56
  • A.J. Preller Shows Off the Japanese he Learned to Recruit Shohei Ohtani + Pitching Has Mets Off To Hot Start
    Apr 22, 2025 – 55:40
  • Reacting to Juan Soto's Comments + Alex Cora Admits This Red Sox Season Feels Different
    Apr 15, 2025 – 50:16
  • How Vladimir Guerrero Jr’s Extension Impacts Pete Alonso + Buster Posey Talks Giants Hot Start
    Apr 8, 2025 – 52:02
  • Torpedo Bats Explained by Official Bat of MLB CEO
    Apr 2, 2025 – 44:03
  • Keith Hernandez Shares Expectations for Mets + Filling Out MLB Bingo Card
    Mar 24, 2025 – 51:41
  • Yankees Likely Leadoff Hitter Austin Wells Joins! + Dodgers Start With Sweep In Tokyo
    Mar 19, 2025 – 42:26
  • Clay Holmes on His Transition to the Starting Rotation + Can Yankees Survive Without Gerrit Cole?
    Mar 12, 2025 – 51:42
  • Michael Kay on Biggest Yankees Questions Heading Into the Season + Will MLB Reinstate Pete Rose?
    Mar 7, 2025 – 54:19
  • Mets Rotation is Banged Up, Finding a Marcus Stroman Trade + NYM Outfielder Brandon Nimmo
    Feb 25, 2025 – 58:05
  • Early Observations of Mets, Yankees Spring Training + NYM Pitching Coach Jeremy Hefner
    Feb 20, 2025 – 50:01
  • Yankees, Mets Final Offseason Grades + NYY Manager Aaron Boone
    Feb 11, 2025 – 54:31
  • Pete Alonso is Back in Queens + Former Mets DH J.D. Martinez Joins!
    Feb 6, 2025 – 58:27
  • Feels Like Pete Alonso Wants Mets More Than Mets Want Alonso + Dodgers GM Brandon Gomes
    Jan 28, 2025 – 57:39
  • Pete Alonso Is A Victim Of His Time, One Real Issue With The Dodgers + Hall of Fame w/ Jayson Stark
    Jan 28, 2025 – 52:13
  • Where Things Stand with Pete Alonso, What's Next for Yankees + Mets Legend David Wright
    Jan 14, 2025 – 59:48
  • Offseason as a free agent, active A's & becoming a foodie w/ Mark Canha
    Jan 9, 2025 – 46:34
  • Juan Soto Signs with Mets & Yankees Start Pivot with Max Fried
    Dec 12, 2024 – 36:49
  • Is Signing Juan Soto Actually in Yankees Best Interest, Mets Interested in Clay Holmes as a Starting Pitcher + Hall of Fame Ballot w/ Dan O'Dowd & Brian Kenny
    Dec 3, 2024 – 59:25
  • Juan Soto Decision Getting Closer & Hall of Fame Ballot with Chris "Mad Dog" Russo
    Nov 26, 2024 – 48:30
  • Juan Soto Sweepstakes Update, Roki Sasaki is Coming to MLB + Yankees P Luke Weaver
    Nov 13, 2024 – 01:04:38
  • Fundamentals Cost Yankees the World Series, Juan Soto Sweepstakes Begin + Mets Manager Carlos Mendoza
    Nov 6, 2024 – 54:22
  • Yankees Season is on Life Support + CF Harrison Bader on Mets Magical Run
    Oct 29, 2024 – 53:34
  • Yankees Are Back in the World Series, Mets Run Out of Magic + Likely AL Cy Young Winner Tarik Skubal
    Oct 23, 2024 – 50:20
  • Mark Vientos Powers Mets to Split in LA, Yankees Are Out-Talenting Guardians + World Series Champion Manager Dusty Baker
    Oct 16, 2024 – 56:14
  • Mets Have 'Team of Destiny' Vibes, Aaron Judge Needs To Be Aaron Judge & Orioles GM Mike Elias on Early Playoff Exit
    Oct 9, 2024 – 57:41
  • Mets Magic Rolls On, Yankees Pressure Could Rise & The Playoffs Are Wide Open
    Oct 2, 2024 – 34:29
  • Can Mets Conquer Braves Demons, Pressure is on Yankees in Postseason & Keith Hernandez on NYM Down the Stretch
    Sep 25, 2024 – 51:57
  • Francisco Lindor is Hurt, Crucial Postseason for Aaron Boone & Ken Rosenthal Makes His World Series Predictions
    Sep 18, 2024 – 01:01:14
  • MVP Races Are Still Up For Debate, Yankees Finally Call Up Jasson Dominguez & Sean Manaea on Mets Playoff Push
    Sep 10, 2024 – 50:54
  • Yankees Need a New Closer, Francisco Lindor Making Late Push For NL MVP & Ryan Dempster on Red-Hot Cubs
    Sep 4, 2024 – 01:01:03
  • Pat Murphy Talks First-Place Brewers
    Aug 27, 2024 – 50:10
  • Luis Severino Talks Mets Playoff Hopes, Strong Season
    Aug 19, 2024 – 47:47
  • Jameson Taillon Talks Cubs Season, Trade Deadline
    Aug 13, 2024 – 58:53
  • Tommy Pham Talks Trade to Cardinals
    Aug 6, 2024 – 01:00:43
  • MLB Trade Deadline Winners and Losers
    Jul 31, 2024 – 35:10
  • Ron Darling Talks Mets Deadline Plans, “Best Booth” in MLB
    Jul 23, 2024 – 51:10
  • Bob Costas Talks All-Star Game, Career, Olympics
    Jul 18, 2024 – 01:01:04
  • Michael Kay Talks Yankees Recent Struggles
    Jul 10, 2024 – 57:39
  • Chris Antonetti Talks Guardians’ Strong Season, Deadline
    Jul 2, 2024 – 50:10
  • David Cone Previews The Subway Series
    Jun 25, 2024 – 46:20
  • Brandon Hyde Talks Orioles' Success, Yankees Matchup
    Jun 18, 2024 – 44:20
  • John Sterling Talks Broadcasting Career, Retirement
    Jun 11, 2024 – 51:23
  • Royals GM J.J. Picollo Talks Impressive Season Thus Far
    Jun 4, 2024 – 44:15
  • Darryl Strawberry Talks Mets Number Retirement
    May 28, 2024 – 52:11
  • Dave Dombrowski Talks First Place Phillies
    May 21, 2024 – 49:19
  • Sandy Alderson Talks Mets’ Tenure, Eppler, Phantom IL
    May 14, 2024 – 54:07
  • Derek Falvey Talks Twins Success, “Rally Sausage”
    May 9, 2024 – 45:45
  • Jeremy Hefner Talks Mets Pitching, Injuries
    Apr 30, 2024 – 46:15
Recent Reviews
  • 80'sVillager
    Hey Dopes!
    Lindor with his good not great 844 OPS is not even in the top 20 of Mets best seasons. Cleon in 69 had a 904. Strawberry 981. Conforto 939. Piazza 1012. Delgado 909. Reyes 877. Lindor .844.
  • Jbmayo
    The show
    The best baseball podcast by far, the knowledge they have and the way they share it is fantastic. They never take themselves seriously but they seriously love the game and it shows. They even have me liking the Yankees & Mets…a little bit.
  • tired of SW check in
    Great show
    Week after week, J & J put together a smart and honest baseball show. Savvy hosts with decades of baseball journalistic experience and insight. MLB in the digital age is much more focused and fun with this podcast.
  • Eric N. S.
    Great show
    Good writers good chemistry - wish they were at a better newspaper
  • Donny’s Baseball luv!
    The Baseball servants
    They have been the go to Guys for me , there podcast is terrific and they are the standard.
  • JasonSS24
    Great baseball podcast
    Best baseball podcast, hosted by two great baseball sportswriters. Top notch guests every week including GMs, managers, players, etc.
  • mjk9825
    The show
    Thanks for a great 2023 season. Even a non New Yorker like me can enjoy it. Looking forward to the new year
  • LGCrew
    Great show every week.
    Knowledgeable co-hosts.
  • AJG1423
    Great Podcast.
    Great podcast. Great guests. I look forward to it each week.
  • K. Lombardo
    Showing Up
    Great listen. Call me crazy but Jon’s a lovable lug!
  • Professional Wingman
    Great Content / Insight BUT…
    It’s a shame, Joel & Jon have such great insight and knowledge to share, and yet I can barely understand them because they speak so quickly. Where’s the fire guys? I will continue to listen for now but can we slow it down just a tad. Thanks!
  • Droithomme
    GREAT SHOW
    Two of the best baseball reporters. I look forward to every episodel Keep it up guys!!!
  • Matt7764
    Stay away
    These are two of the worst “reporters” in baseball. Stay away and don’t trust what they say. They’re just looking for clicks, they don’t care about accurately portraying the current events or news in baseball.
  • RE9410
    Hacks
    Jon Heyman should retire in shame he is the ultimate hack writer and he’s a perfect fit for a rag like the embarrassing NY Post. Sherman is also a clown but he’s not as bad as that cheap tan donkey.
  • NJZ3D
    Great show….but if you interrupt you won’t get your $20 tip
    I thoroughly enjoy the interaction in discussions between Joel Sherman and John Heyman. Their different personalities work well as they bounce their opinions and ideas off each other.
  • mago243
    Busssssiiiiinnnnn podcast
    Insane
  • Oz Q
    Best in Class
    If you’re a baseball fan you have to listen to this podcast. It is by far the best. Great commentary, great analysis, and great guests. They’ve been in the baseball business for a long time and they know their stuff.
  • P. 👨‍🦲☘️
    Excellent.
    Excellent presentations on all fronts. This podcast is going to be super successful as the hosts are true professionals and come across as decent gentlemen.
  • winapieforit
    Great duo
    My only gripe is that there is only 1 episode a week.
  • bigvig5656
    Great match
    You guys are a great match together. Great interviews so far I’m enjoying the show
  • Ken gut
    Work well together
    Great interviewers ,all the topics are very relevant. One of my favorite podcasts I listen to listen , and I listen to a lot
  • FrankyPop
    Boras
    Is boring
  • aefpa
    Dynamic Duo
    There’s a lot going on here- years of experience as baseball journalists which leads to story after story about all of the games, the seasons, the characters they’ve covered, the controversies, the changes in the game, their ideas of how it should all be done. Fast moving conversation fueled by gallons of coffee, and plenty of zingers. Impressive roster of guests. For anyone who loves baseball.
  • stratm3
    What a Duo!
    This pod is hosted by two preeminent journalists of the New York Baseball scene. It’s truly a gem of a podcast!
  • Baseballdog07
    Great Podcast
    What an outstanding podcast! So nice to have a baseball podcast with hosts who are so knowledgeable and are not plugging only their network related baseball games/topics while ignoring all other MLB news and notes. Now I have a reason to look forward to Tuesdays.
  • YankeeWolverine
    Pragmatic - Measured - Expert - Good Guys
    I’ve always appreciated Jon Heyman for his self deprecating humor and his not too serious take on baseball. Joel Sherman is a pretty good foil as he’s a lot feistier but doesn’t have stupid hot takes or go on silly rants. Bottom line is these guys are fun to listen to and they never stray too far from the subject of the show which is baseball. Also, they’d be great to have a beer with. I hope this show lasts a long time.
  • PeterParkerNJ
    Love it!
    If you love baseball you’ll love this podcast! These guys are fantastic 👍🏻👍🏻
  • zardoz790
    Finally: a terrific baseball podcast
    Sensible, informed, topical. No hot takes. Just great sports reporting.
  • CrownMeSteven
    Wow
    Great insightful podcast from two of the best in the Media!!
  • MoniRuffles
    The BEST baseball podcast!
    Insightful and interesting. Never miss it.
  • julianoleo
    My only issue!!!
    We need this podcast at least 2-3 times a week not just every Tuesday!!! Great show guys!!! I would love a shoutout!!!
  • Cheese60
    👍⚾️
    Great info and entertainment for a baseball fan
  • WP Cat Lady
    Excellent Baseball Insights!
    I’m not a “podcast” fan, but these 2 longtime baseball journalists are so knowledgeable! It’s a pleasure listen to them both. They complement each other very well, and each have their own unique perspectives! They bring their own personality, but it doesn’t overshadow or interfere with the actual “baseball reporting!” (So many podcasts waste time on irrelevant “banter,” an immediate turn-off & unsubscribe from me.) Huge fan! 💗
  • RJ from NJ
    Excellent listen
    Two very knowledgeable baseball columnists who are easy on the ears. Great job!
  • nimsy nomura
    TOTAL ABSOLUTE GEM
    This is so perfect and impossible to duplicate: two of the very best baseball writers who are also the very best of friends sharing with the world what a lucky few of us got to overhear in press boxes since they first met on the Yankees beat 30 years ago. Their knowledge, information, intelligence, and wit is surpassed only by their authentic chemistry. If you’re remotely interested in MLB today, this absolutely should be No. 1 on your playlist.
  • Downtownhb1
    Terrific baseball cast
    This is the best baseball podcast out there from two no nonsense seasoned pros. The best insights on the game. I do wish it were a little longer but for baseball fans this is an absolute can’t miss!
  • Lou.V7
    Must listen for baseball fans!
    I was excited to hear that my 2 favorite baseball writers are doing a podcast. After only 2 shows I can say they did not disappoint. Hopefully the podcasts will be a little longer as they go forward. A must listen if you like great baseball talk!
  • baseballfan1918
    LOVED THE POD
    Just listened to the first episode. I wish this was more then once a week. Love following and reading these guys. This is definitely a must listen. Keep up the great work!!!
  • Samba Simba
    My Tuesday Must Listen! Two of the very best
    Jon & Joel are two of the most insightful baseball writers out there. I am thrilled to hear them on this platform. If you are a baseball fan, this is a must listen!
  • JoeyGebbia
    Joel and Jon
    can’t wait!!! love these two from the MLB network
Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork on this page are property of the podcast owner, and not endorsed by UP.audio.